The Ultimate Rental Property Checklist: Avoid Buying a Dud

Investing in rental properties can be a great way to build wealth and generate passive income. However, many new investors fall into costly traps that can lead to financial loss. To help you avoid these pitfalls, I've compiled a comprehensive rental property checklist based on my personal experiences of owning over 57 properties. This guide is designed to ensure you make informed decisions and create a sustainable investment portfolio.

1. Prioritize Cash Flow

Before diving into any property investment, the first thing to consider is cash flow. Forget about appreciation or potential equity; your primary concern should be whether the property generates positive net income. This means calculating all expenses, including:

• Principal and interest on the mortgage

• Taxes

• Insurance

• Property management fees

• Vacancy reserves (typically around 5%)

• Capital expenditure (CapEx) and maintenance reserves (around 10%)

• Any other potential costs, like utilities

If the numbers don’t add up to a positive cash flow, walk away. This principle alone could save you from making significant mistakes, as it did for me with several poorly performing properties.

2. Know Your Market

Your knowledge of the market is vital. Zip codes alone don't tell the full story. You need to understand where people want to live and where they’re trying to escape from. Here are some strategies to gain insight:

• Drive through neighborhoods at different times of the day.

• Look for signs of life—cars, foot traffic, and trash cans can tell you a lot about the area.

• Utilize Google Earth to investigate properties further.

• Talk to local authorities, like police and postal workers, who can provide honest insights.

If you’re investing out of state, having a trusted local contact is crucial. This person should be an experienced operator familiar with the area, not just a wholesaler trying to make a quick buck.

3. The 1% Rule Explained

The 1% rule is a useful filter to determine if a property is worth your time. This rule states that the monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. However, remember that it’s just a quick check and not a guarantee. I’ve purchased properties with lower percentages that performed exceptionally well due to low maintenance costs and great tenants. Conversely, I've seen properties with higher percentages that turned out to be financial nightmares. Use this rule cautiously and always look at the bigger picture.

4. Get the Real Numbers

Don't take the seller's word for it. Always request the last 12 months of actual income and expenses. This includes:

• Current leases

• Proof of rent payments

• Utility bills

• Contractor invoices for recent repairs

Verify everything. I once bought a property that seemed fantastic until I found out the tenants hadn’t paid rent in three months, and the seller had been covering it up. Doing your homework upfront can save you from costly surprises later.

5. Always Have an Exit Strategy

Having an exit strategy isn’t about being fearful; it’s about having options. Ask yourself what you would do if you had to sell the property in six months. Consider the following:

• Can you sell it to another investor?

• Can it be financed by a homeowner?

• Can you convert it into a short-term rental?

Flexibility is key. A solid exit strategy can protect you from being stuck in a bad situation.

6. Property Management Plan

Your property management plan should be in place before you close on a property. Even if you plan to manage it yourself, consider what might happen if life throws you a curveball. Speak to local property managers and ask key questions, such as:

• How do you handle non-payment?

• What’s your process for raising rents?

• How often do you inspect properties?

My experience taught me that choosing the right property manager is crucial. I once had a manager raise rents by 15% without informing me, leading to a mass exodus of tenants.

7. CapEx and Condition Check

Understand the true condition of the property. Don’t just focus on cosmetic issues like paint. Investigate major components such as:

• Roof

• HVAC systems

• Plumbing and electrical systems

• Foundation

If you can’t afford a significant repair, you’re playing with fire. Always get a full inspection and budget for unexpected costs by adding a contingency of at least 10-15%.

8. Legal, Insurance, and Regulatory Risks

Know the legal landscape of the area you’re investing in. Are you in a tenant-friendly or landlord-friendly state? Understand the eviction laws and insurance requirements. For instance, I once bought a property in a historical zone where I couldn't make any changes without special permits. Research these aspects thoroughly to avoid costly mistakes.

9. Trust Your Gut

Sometimes, your instincts can be your best guide. If something feels off, it probably is. If the seller is acting shady or if the property gives you a bad vibe, it’s okay to walk away. I’ve ignored my gut before, and it always cost me. Always remember: there will be other deals.

10. Standard Operating Procedures (SOP)

Finally, consider your operational procedures. If you can’t set up a system to manage the property without your daily involvement, you’re buying a job instead of an investment. Focus on building systems that support your life and financial goals. This is why I teach these principles in my Rental Property Academy, where we focus on creating sustainable investment strategies.

Conclusion: Your Turn to Take Action

Now that you have this checklist, print it out and make it your go-to guide. Use it to filter out properties that don't meet your criteria and protect your financial future. If you found this information valuable, please share it with others who may benefit. Remember, I’m here to help you avoid the mistakes I made over the years. If you're ready to take your investing to the next level, consider joining my Rental Property Academy for a deeper dive into all these principles and more.

Are you a veteran or first responder looking to start your journey toward financial freedom through real estate? Visit Bud Evans Consulting and sign up for a free strategy session today. Let’s turn your dreams into reality!

Check out my YouTube!

I post real estate investment videos weekly!