Don't Buy Section 8 Until You See This — A Straight-Talk Field Manual for Landlords

I'm Bud Evans, and I invest in Section 8. If you've heard the pitch — "guaranteed rent" — it sounds like a windfall. But there’s more under the hood. I've run Section 8 units, called Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) tenants, and worked through the wins and the headaches. This is your practical, no BS field manual: what works, what doesn't, and the exact processes you need so inspections, paperwork, and the tenant selection process don't blindside you.

Quick primer: What is Section 8 (HCV)?

Section 8, officially the Housing Choice Voucher program, is a federal support program that helps low- to moderate-income households pay rent. Qualified tenants receive a voucher that covers a portion — sometimes up to 100% — of rent directly to the landlord. How much the program pays depends on local payment standards, rent reasonableness comparisons, and the unit's bedroom count/type.

In short: the program can deliver steady rent and a deep pool of applicants — but it comes with rules, inspections, and a third party (the housing authority) in your landlord-tenant equation.

The upside: Why section 8 deserves serious consideration

• Predictable rent

  — Once the unit passes inspection and the contract is active, the housing authority typically pays the program portion monthly on schedule. In weak rental markets, that predictability is gold.

• Large demand pool

  — Getting into HCV is slow; voucher holders are actively searching for places. If your unit is set up right, it can lease quickly.

• Longer tenancies

  — Voucher tenants often stay longer than market-rate tenants, lowering turnover, make-ready costs, and vacancy loss.

• Recession resistance

  — Demand for HUD-assisted housing holds or rises in downturns, cushioning your portfolio when market rents dip.

The friction: What most landlords don't tell you

I'm not going to sugarcoat this. Section 8 will expose any weakness in your systems. Here are the real friction points:

• Inspections before you get paid

  — The unit must pass HUD Housing Quality Standards (HQS). Fail and you fix, then wait for reinspection. No pass = no payment. Timing depends on your local authority and can be painfully slow.

• Rent reasonableness and payment standards

  — You don't set the final number alone. The housing authority compares your rent to local comps. If your rent is above market or your payment standard is low, the program portion will be cut. Check your local payment standards before underwriting.

• Paperwork and timelines

  — Contract signatures, W-9s, direct deposit forms, lease packets — these take time. Expect initial lag between move-in and first payment. Plan for it.

• Common inspection fail items

  — Smoke & CO detectors, GFCIs, handrails, window locks, peeling paint, trip hazards. These are frequent fail points — have a pre-inspection checklist and handyman ready.

• Tenant income drift

  — The tenant's share can go up or down as their income changes. That means month-to-month variability you must track in your ledger.

• Third-party compliance

  — You still follow landlord-tenant law, but now there's a third party involved. Serious lease breaches require documentation and notification to the housing authority before action.

Who should consider Section 8 — and who shouldn't

Section 8 is not for everyone. Consider it if:

• You operate clean, safe units and don't cut corners on rehabs.

• You value steady income and lower turnover more than squeezing the last dollar from top-of-market rents.

• You can run checklists, manage inspections, and file clean paperwork.

• Your market's payment standards support your target returns.

Think twice if:

• Your business model relies on premium rents well above local comps.

• You resist inspections or don't want to be told to make repairs.

• Your cash flow can't survive a few weeks’ delay at lease-up.

• You don't have SOPs for compliance and documentation.

Six critical questions to answer before you say yes

1. Does the unit meet HQS today?

   Be honest: loose handrails, missing GFCIs, peeling paint = fail.

2. Do local payment standards support your rent goal?

   If your pro forma needs $2,350 for a three-bed but the standard is $1,950, you have a gap to solve.

3. What’s your all-in return at the payment standard?

   Run the numbers after taxes, insurance, utilities (if you pay them), management fees, repair reserves, and debt service.

4. Do you have the team?

   Reliable handyman, quick-turn cleaner, property manager who knows the housing authority processes.

5. Is your tenant screening bulletproof?

   Voucher status is not a free pass. You still need background checks, landlord references, and income verification for the tenant share.

6. Are you prepared for paperwork and timelines?

   Clean lease packet, W-9, direct deposit — be ready to respond fast.

How to set up a Section 8 unit to pass on the first inspection

Save weeks — and money — with a pre-inspection routine. Here’s my field checklist:

• Write an HQS-style pre-check in Google Docs and walk the unit like an inspector.

• Test every smoke and CO detector. Replace batteries and units if defective.

• Verify GFCIs are installed and trip properly at required locations (kitchen, bathrooms).

• Check all windows open, close, and lock. Make sure they stay open where required.

• Add handrails where needed. Cap open plumbing, cover junction boxes, and secure loose outlets.

• Scrape and repaint peeling surfaces; pay attention to windowsills and thresholds.

• Confirm water temperature and no leaks. Check hot water works at the proper temp.

• Address pest issues before inspection.

• Date-stamp photos of the unit condition before inspection — they’re invaluable if disputes arise.

Schedule the inspection when your handyman can be on-site. Get paperwork in order: W-9, direct deposit info, lease packet. Sloppy paperwork causes avoidable delays.

Rent reasonableness: If you upgrade, document it

The authority will compare your rent to similar units. If you've done meaningful upgrades — new kitchen, bath, luxury vinyl plank, energy-efficient fixtures — document everything: photos, receipts, specs. This documentation helps justify higher rent within the payment standard. For renewals, many markets allow annual increases if the market supports them. Learn your jurisdiction's calendar notice window so you don't miss your opportunity.

Tenant selection: Screening is the real lever

Voucher holders are people — not a single category. Your job is to match the resident to your property standards. Use clear expectation scripts on walkthroughs:

Require contact info for current and prior landlords and call them. Ask two direct questions: "Would you rent to them again?" and "Is there anything I should know that would surprise me?" If the answers are "no" or there's a red flag, move on. Don't force a bad fit because they have a voucher.

Common myths debunked

• Section 8 tenants don't take care of properties

  — Some do, some don't. Screening and expectations matter more than voucher status.

• "I'll always get paid"

  — The program portion is steady once active, but the tenant portion is on the tenant. You still collect and enforce late payments.

• "The authority will cover damage"

  — No. You still need security deposits, move-in condition photos, and a strong lease.

• "It's too much red tape"

  — It’s a process. If you run checklists and SOPs, it's manageable. If you wing it, it will become a headache.

Simple numbers example to fast-check decision speed

Example: three-bed payment standard = $2,000; rent reasonableness supports $1,950. Tenant share = $300; program pays $1,650.

• Taxes + insurance + utilities + management = $900/month

• Debt service = $800/month

• Total expense = $1,700/month

• Net cash flow at $1,950 rent = $250/month ($3,000/year)

If your DSCR or cash flow targets need more cushion, this won't work. Numbers first; story second. If the math doesn't hit your thresholds at the payment standard, pass.

Operating rhythm: A repeatable process that minimizes surprises

1. Pre-showing: run your pre-inspection checklist and fix everything.

2. During application: full screening, clear expectations, confirm tenant share.

3. Paperwork: submit a clean packet; respond to housing authority requests same day.

4. Inspection: be present or have a knowledgeable representative and handyman attend.

5. Move-in: walkthrough video, signed condition form by both parties.

6. Monthly: reconcile ledger, confirm program payment posted, follow up on tenant share immediately if late.

7. Quarterly: light maintenance walkthroughs (filters, safety hazards, leaks).

8. Annually: review rent reasonableness and document upgrades for renewal increases.

When Section 8 is a bad fit vs. a strong fit

Bad fit:

• High-end renovations in markets where payment standards lag.

• Unique properties with no local comps for rent reasonableness.

• Business models that can't tolerate a few weeks of initial payment lag.

Strong fit:

• Clean, safe, mid-level units near transit, schools, and jobs.

• Markets where payment standards align with your pro forma.

• Investors with systems, a stable team, and a preference for occupancy stability over squeezing the last rent dollar.

Decision framework: Six checks before you green-light a voucher

1. Market check

   — Confirm payment standards and vacancy trends locally.

2. Unit check

   — Run and pass your pre-inspection checklist.

3. Math check

   — Underwrite using the payment standard, not wishful rent.

4. Team check

   — Confirm your lender, manager, handyman, and inspection coordinator are ready.

5. Tenant fit

   — Screen like a pro and get solid references.

6. Paperwork discipline

   — Clean packets, fast responses, and date tracking.

If all six are green, move forward. If any are a hard no, fix the gap or pass.

Final thoughts

Section 8 isn't a magic pill — and it's not a trap. It's a tool in your investing toolbox. Used correctly, it stabilizes income, reduces turnover, and gives recession-proof demand. Used casually, it will jam you up with delays, failed inspections, and thin returns. Ask yourself: do I want stability and systems? Am I willing to run checklists and play by the rules? Does the math work at local payment standards?

If yes, Section 8 can be a strategic win. If not, pick the lane that matches your goals. If you want help making this decision for your market and unit mix, get expert guidance and a checklist from someone who's done it: a strategy session can get you started with a plan that fits your goals and risk tolerance.

Execute fast. Aim high. Build systems that protect your time and returns. If you follow the checklist, the inspections, the paperwork, and the screening — Section 8 can be one of the most stabilizing arrows in your quiver.

Check out my YouTube!

I post real estate investment videos weekly!